It's the Premier League, stupid

Richard Scudamore

As much as I admire the resolve of the Fratton Park marchers, you have to question the likely outcome.

Will a few dozen fans delivering a letter to Fratton Park make a penny worth of difference to the intentions of the faceless people that own Portsmouth Football Club? Barclays Bank included. I doubt it.

You can understand the fans' frustrations. The media's whipping boys one minute and the target of HMRC investigations and winding up orders the next. Couple this to some of the poorest financial management ever to be witnessed in world football and you have a Club hanging on by its finger nails.

To suggest though that this situation has arisen at the hands of Mark Jacob and his employers, is of course naive. And understandably Jacob and co are at odds to point this out. Claiming not to have been aware of the extent of the Club's debts and even threatening amidst the wise cracks to sue Sacha Gaydamak.

Why threaten to sue? Choose your own reasons, but I can't help thinking it has something to do with Gaydamak playing the game a little better than Jacob and Co, especially when you consider that Sacha along with Barclays still owns the majority of the land in the immediate vicinity of Fratton Park.

In short it would seem that Sacha remains in control of the most of the assets and Al Faraj and advisors got lumped with the debt. No wonder they are miffed.

But how come businessmen cited by Storrie as taking PFC to another level, bought into the Club without the necessary means to manage it?  Clearly they had no idea what they were getting themselves into and even if they did, at best they had underestimated the demands of running a Premier League team that is still reeling from the excesses of the Redknapp inspired spend to the end gold rush.

But such oversights are not restricted to football and the well wishing marchers shouldn't take it so personally. The owners, whether with good intentions or bad, are symptoms of the modern day game and as such are guilty of no more than exploiting a commercial opportunity, which you can't help thinking, was 'sold' to them by a senior figure at Fratton Park. No wonder Jacob has been bought in. How could the previous management be left in charge when the sticker price on Fratton Park contained a few too many zeros and apparently too little in the way of accurate documentation?

Ultimately though, man will do what man will do and that's why we have laws, rules and regulations to curb the excesses of the human race. Or that's the idea in any case.

The trouble is top flight football's rule makers, in this case the Premier League and to some extent the F.A, seem more intent in chasing the green stuff than they do ensuring the Clubs are healthy enough to play on it. Take the Prem's Chief Exec as an example. Richard 'play it overseas' Scudamore, earned a Storrie beating £1.5m last year, with over £700,000 of that being paid in bonuses for negotiating ever higher TV deals. That's 50% of his remuneration dedicated to driving up TV revenues and all the consequences that come with it.

I ask you, how stupid can these people be? What is the point of throwing more money at the game. We still play with eleven players and give or take, the support staff remains fairly static. So where does the money go? Simple. Into inflation busting transfer fees and player salaries and anything that is left over ends up in the pockets of the owners or the execs.  Under soil heating anyone?

We see average players earning more in a week than most of us do in a year and so called superstars earning sums so obscene that we all collectively gasp when it makes the news. And does the game improve because of this influx of cash? Does it hell. Anybody who thinks Rooney and Co are providing the public with better entertainment than the stars of, for example the 70s and 80s, really do need their footballing heads examined.

The fact is the financial culture that now rules our game is being driven by those who run football. Last year I had several off the record chats with Premier League spokespersons about the general situation at Fratton Park and the state of the game in general. Trying to get a rational response was like trying to get Redknapp to acknowledge his part in the demise of any of the clubs he has managed.

They were quick to remind me that new TV deals had been negotiated, but didn't or couldn't give decent answers as to why the foundations of the game are being undermined by people and practices whose motives are anything but aligned with the interests of the game.

On asking the Prem why they didn't take a more proactive role in checking out prospective new owners, I was told it was for the law of the land to administer and wasn't really their remit beyond the clearly myopic Fit & Proper checks that were already in place. A clear if implied acknowledgement that as long as prospective owners don't have an obvious criminal record then they are deemed to be fit and proper. So much for all the fuss that delayed Al Fahim's appointment back in the summer.

And when Al Faraj came along, exactly what checks took place then? Did the league check out his ability to meet even a single month's payroll? I wonder.

I think we all know the answer  to that and if we don't and we are wrong then there has to be something else adrift when players who take off their shirt can get randomly booked and consequently red carded, yet major structural issues at the very heart of the game go unaddressed.

And now we witness the Prem withholding Pompey's TV money even though the Club's claiming it's unlawful.

Whoever is right, one thing is for sure. The Prem okayed the transfer of Pompey's Prem franschise to Al Faraj and possibly much more significantly, authorised each and every transfer in and out of the Club.

Didn't any of those ever so clever people at the Prem stop to think that the Club with the lowest ground capacity in the League and with a series of owners that were richish at best, may not be able to fund huge salaries and massive fees to clubs and agents without something breaking?  Yet they went ahead and authorised the transfers and now it's gone belly up they are adding to the Club's problems by interfering with our attempts to stay in the league. And if that doesn't scupper us, they've always got the threat of the feared points deduction to put things beyond any doubt.

As I said, it's the Premier League, stupid.


Posted Sun, Jan 17 2010 7:26 PM by c h r i s
Filed under:

Comments

mike c wrote re: It's the Premier League, stupid
on Sun, Jan 17 2010 8:03 PM

It is a good piece and all that can be said is the future of the club is the most important thing now. Will there be a pompey?. We the fans are the ones being rubbished and our club a laughing stock! Let's hope the owners stop to think about what they bought and what it means to us the fans!

Goldenboot wrote re: It's the Premier League, stupid
on Sun, Jan 17 2010 8:04 PM

Yes rocking article Chris,

I wish the Pompey fans would march on the FA headquarters and hand them a letter

Phil wrote re: It's the Premier League, stupid
on Sun, Jan 17 2010 8:37 PM

Good article. I'm getting fed up with the whole situation at the moment, as I expect many fans are. I will still be at FP when what happened to Aldershot happens to us and we then have to start fighting our way up.

c h r i s wrote re: It's the Premier League, stupid
on Sun, Jan 17 2010 8:39 PM

Boot, prior to a mid-week London away game makes most sense. We are away to Fulham on Wednesday 3rd Feb.

Goldenboot wrote re: It's the Premier League, stupid
on Sun, Jan 17 2010 8:43 PM

also .. you would of thought the local MP's would be asking questions of the sports minister .. in parliment

.. disgraceful way in which the Fa has treated the club/city

athleticpete wrote re: It's the Premier League, stupid
on Sun, Jan 17 2010 8:51 PM

Pompey fans marching on the FA would probably not change the situation. They are quite happy to see a ´small´club disappear as long as the TV money comes flooding in.

However if we could join forces with Liverpool and Man U fans....then it might make a difference.

pompeymac wrote re: It's the Premier League, stupid
on Sun, Jan 17 2010 8:52 PM

Great article Chris.

If fans were to protest at the FA HQ what do you think would be the outcome?

Obviously there would be a lot of media coverage but do you think it would make a difference?

I would love to think it would and they would be embarrassed and/or motivated to do something but I fear we would just be brushed under the carpet.

Don't get me wrong. I am all for it and if there is to be protests then they should be directed at the FA instead of the PFC board.

But I just get the feeling that nobody cares about little old Pompey apart from us fans!

c h r i s wrote re: It's the Premier League, stupid
on Sun, Jan 17 2010 9:25 PM

Pete, Mac - I think this is Prem/FA issue and if a demonstration will work anywhere then I think it would best outside their offices in full view of the world.

It may not have the same effect as yesterday's letter which resulted in 'Jacob let us in for a cosy stockholm syndrome inducing chat, but it may well prompt the FA to look at the bigger issue.

Obviously that may not work for us in the short term... but will getting Al Farah to talk more actually solve our problems? I doubt it. He'll just be replaced by another and another. It's the rules that need changing not the owners.

I like the idea of there being a general protest with fans from other teams. In which case it would need to focus on a theme common to us all... ownership springs to mind coupled to how they fund club acquisitions and how much they borrow once in.

EBz wrote re: It's the Premier League, stupid
on Sun, Jan 17 2010 9:33 PM

Lovely article Chris. As always, compelling reading in brilliant style!

Chix wrote re: It's the Premier League, stupid
on Sun, Jan 17 2010 10:14 PM

Hi Chris .. Great article and very thought provoking.. Me? I'm just sick to the back teeth of the whole sorry debacle - Who's right? who's wrong? who knows anymore? Let's just hope (irrespective of what happens to Pompey) that somebody at the Premier League takes a good hard look at the situation you refer too... Sadly though I wouldn't put a fiver on it !

PFCPompeyBoy wrote re: It's the Premier League, stupid
on Sun, Jan 17 2010 10:45 PM

A brilliant piece, and some good comments.  One think i did like is getting te government to get involved and ask the premier league for answers.    Isnt there a Website where people create petitions asking the government to do this that and the other? if so maybe this artcle could be posted as the body of a petition to lobby the government to investigate this situation?  I am sure we would have more than the 20,000 fans sign it, as the same is happening throughout over half the clubs and no one is interested?

Graham FACT wrote re: It's the Premier League, stupid
on Sun, Jan 17 2010 10:58 PM

Thought-provoking indeed.  I recently asked the lawyers representing the Supporters Trust if there is a case against the Premier League "means test" as it doesn't seem like a fit and proper test if the new owners (x2) can't pay the wage bill. Also when convicted fraudsters start drifting-in via the backdoor what then ??

Danny wrote re: It's the Premier League, stupid
on Sun, Jan 17 2010 11:52 PM

The thing is, yes it's a good read, but did you write something similar when your rivals up the road were suffering? Or Leeds or Luton or even Bournemouth? Probably not... I actually don't disagree but I wrote something like your above prior to Southamptons slide and when we were being taken over I hadto endure much mocking from fratton faithful who thought it funny that you had an Arab billionaire. I said then what I say now. I don't want to be a Man City! I'm happy with taking it slowly. It'd be nicer to win something organically. Otherwise a Man City/Chelsea fan celebrating a league win is somehow like winning a horse race when you knobbled the result.

That said I hope you get out of this but I still think too many fans of too many clubs are a bit two faced/ one sided when looking at things like this.

insideright.(west of hamble river..S.F.C.) wrote re: It's the Premier League, stupid
on Sun, Jan 17 2010 11:55 PM

It would be like trying to sue Barclays for letting my missus run up such a hugh credit card bill. My team went into administration for 4m..... if your team gets a clean slate for 60m then surely that is a result ! Part of me feels sorry for you having to fire sale your good players.........but then part of me can't stop laughing at the fact that you are sponsered by "jobsite". ........      pay up pompey ! X

Iain McInnes wrote re: It's the Premier League, stupid
on Mon, Jan 18 2010 12:04 AM

The Premier League conduct a forensic investigation into the financial affairs of it's members.....do me a favour......do turkeys vote for Xmas!

What's happening in the PL Football Market is so in tune with what we saw with the recent banking crisis it's laughable.

Investment and borrowings against over inflated assets in a business run by self indulgent and in the main short term management teams, based on a market revenue that's forecast to increase in value perpetually.

The PL then cast in the role of Government 'hang the long term consequences, just go with the feel good factor and take the revenue.

Similarities with the housing market? Let's see.......despite the £1.000.000''s penthouse markets and central London hype, when the 1st time buyers left the market it was the main constituent to the virtual collapse in demand. Are we not beginning to see that with the 'ordinary' and traditional football fan but yet to see the longer term consequences?

Poor old Pompey, they'll be glad to see the back of us. The PL'S Northern Rock. Late into the market, spending, lending and borrowing from whoever, wherever in an attempt to gatecrash the party. Incidentally undone by a management team, totally inexperienced but uniquely rewarded for it's limited but spectacular rise to fame!

The difference I'm afraid is the Government to avoid an even bigger crisis had no option but to bail their errant member out.

Could it be that the PL to avoid their 'crisis in the making' has no option other than to throw us out!

Chocky wrote re: It's the Premier League, stupid
on Mon, Jan 18 2010 2:02 AM

Nice words, but I don't remember them being spoken when things were going well. It's all very well blaming the Premier League for poisioning the game and driving up player costs but that's what got Pompey in the PL to start with. Blame the people with no money...

Flipkid wrote re: It's the Premier League, stupid
on Mon, Jan 18 2010 2:14 AM

Smashing write-up, Chris.  Can't wait to see what happens next...

JOHN FRISBEE wrote re: It's the Premier League, stupid
on Mon, Jan 18 2010 6:42 AM

V.G ARTICLE. I would sign a petition, even though I live in

OZ. Our fans have been treated terribly, PS HAS been taking

big wages, he was out in Perth  justa while ago. tHE WAGES

HARRY WAS PAYING PLAYERS, no way,thats where the money went, how much to agents with all those ins and outs.

Also what did he do at Saints and West Ham,he reminds me

of Venables!!!

Pompey,with these Arabs/Jews/chinese need to survive as a

club even if we are down in Div2.

Turk wrote re: It's the Premier League, stupid
on Mon, Jan 18 2010 8:44 AM

Very good and you raised a couple of points I hadn't considered, notably that the EPL authorised the transfers in the first place.

I suspect their administration of the league in general wouldn't pass inspection if it were the subject of an Inquiry. Why an Inquiry? Because it's a £5BN business and it's in danger of collapse.

balance wrote re: It's the Premier League, stupid
on Mon, Jan 18 2010 8:48 AM

Interesting twist on the news this morning, broadcast regulator requires SkySports and SkyMovies to be allowed to be competitively priced by alternative suppliers, eg BT ARE allowed to sell Skysports at £15...that's now legal and binding.

Perhaps the FA have spotted this but you can guess that IF sky are receiving 60% less for their sports subscriptions, there isn't going to be the money there next year...and you can bet Skysports are not going to absorb that revenue loss.

Perhaps a change is in sight, not too sure its going to be good for the players wages or clubs short term survival...may be better in the longer term for clubs and fans though...

Anyone want to put together a scenario and plan for taking PFC over as a social/community enterprise?

PFCPompeyBoy wrote re: It's the Premier League, stupid
on Mon, Jan 18 2010 9:35 AM

I still think we need a petition to the Government asking them Why the Premier league is bringing the national Sport into Disarray and then blaming the clubs.  Yes i agree this is not a Pompey thing, it includes what happened to Southampton, Leeds, Bournemouth etc...  The Football leagues, including the body running the Premier league, DO oversee the transfers, so they must be accountable too.  Surely we want our government to set up an independant body to audit the Premier and FA, before Platini does it via Fifa, and we lose all credability that is already tarnishing fast.

c h r i s wrote re: It's the Premier League, stupid
on Mon, Jan 18 2010 9:46 AM

Hi Chix, Nice to see you here. I trust Vital is doing well.

I do believe we need to move the action to a new level. I can't see what moaning to the owners will achieve... who know's who'll own the Club in the very near future. Do we need to start new action every time it changes hands?

c h r i s wrote re: It's the Premier League, stupid
on Mon, Jan 18 2010 9:48 AM

PFCPompeyBoy, thanks for your comnents. There is a petition facility at the No10 website, but like all these things, you need a critical mass before you make a move for fear of it falling flat if you don't -

Rgds, Chris

c h r i s wrote re: It's the Premier League, stupid
on Mon, Jan 18 2010 9:51 AM

Hello Graham, I note Scudamore is trying to claim that any action by Pompey is an action against itself, given the members own the league... Can't he see that PFC is in dire danger of being excluded from the Prem because of their deliberate actions on the one hand, and quite possibly their negligence on the other.

c h r i s wrote re: It's the Premier League, stupid
on Mon, Jan 18 2010 9:58 AM

Well Danny, had you taken the time to look as some of the other articles on myPompey, you will see that we did cover the plight of others. As for nasty, childish rants against other fans and clubs, it's banned on myPompey, for hopefully obvious reasons.

We all need to pull together on this, immaterial of the club we support. Shame on those that point the finger solely at Pompey, when most of the league is living above its means, with half of those suffering some sort of financial distress.

It can't all be the fault of Pompey and its agrophobic owners.

Good luck at Saints, I for one hope you do well. The south needs strong clubs.

c h r i s wrote re: It's the Premier League, stupid
on Mon, Jan 18 2010 10:00 AM

insideright -

I agree, Jobsite is unfortunate and just goes to show that at least the execs at Pompey have a sense of humour.

In saying that, had they not done the deal, Pompey would be floating bottom up in the Solent by now.

c h r i s wrote re: It's the Premier League, stupid
on Mon, Jan 18 2010 10:13 AM

Iain McInnes

If you see us as Northern Rock then what does that make the Prem? Political lightweights chasing votes and to hell with the consequences?

The Prem and football administration in general wallows in the fact that football is self governing. At FP the police used to come on the pitch and threaten to arrest players if they didn't clean up their act, but now we govern ourselves, both on and off the pitch.

Heaven knows what goes on behind locked doors at FP, Soho Square and so on... nobody really knows the full picture and the only people with the power to review the situation are the government. But, for some reason they seems to believe that market forces and the will of the public should be left to deal with the situation.

The same rationale that lost us our manufacturing base and allows pond life to attend British Universities whilst planning to blow up airliners.

When will this country recover the backbone that once made it great?

c h r i s wrote re: It's the Premier League, stupid
on Mon, Jan 18 2010 10:17 AM

Chocky, you said:

"Nice words, but I don't remember them being spoken when things were going well"

Well, you'd be wrong there. I was one of the few who was vocal about the state of PFC's finances long before we won the Cup. (Chix above, from Vital Pompey), will be one the first to confirm that.

c h r i s wrote re: It's the Premier League, stupid
on Mon, Jan 18 2010 10:24 AM

JOHN FRISBEE

Strange that both Redknapp and Venables ended up at Pompey... maybe we should be looking at ourselves and why we seem to attract them....

c h r i s wrote re: It's the Premier League, stupid
on Mon, Jan 18 2010 10:27 AM

Balance, interesting spot on your part... (can't help laughing that SKY have now been hit with their very own local loop ruling, in the same way that BT was all those years ago).

I reckon you are right tho'. Suddenly there will be a variance in SKY's budget and you can be sure they won't swallow it internally.

I like the idea of a locally owned club, but I fear such a plan could only happen phoenix like, following administration.

c h r i s wrote re: It's the Premier League, stupid
on Mon, Jan 18 2010 10:31 AM

thank you EBz. that's very kind :))

Dan S. wrote re: It's the Premier League, stupid
on Mon, Jan 18 2010 10:38 AM

it's not as if football or Pompey is alone. This year will be terrible for businesses in general, In some respects I'm glad we are being hit now. Had it happened later we might have been one of many, with much less attention focused on keeping US going.

artist wrote re: It's the Premier League, stupid
on Mon, Jan 18 2010 10:52 AM

GREAT PIECE  WORTH THE READ.IT SAYS EVERYTHING.AND SHOWS REALLY HOW LITTLE WE AS SUPPORTERS CAN DO.CLUBS ARE IN THE HANDS OF PEOPLE WHO OPERATE ON WHIMS.THE LEAGUE BOSSES  SEEM TO HAVE NO MORE AUTHORITY OVER THE RUNNING OF CLUBS THAN WE DO THE ONLY DIFFERENCE BEING THEY GET FAT SALARIES.THAT SHOULD ALL CHANGE BUT WHERE WOULD THE POWER COME FROM TO INSTIGATE THAT CHANGE.FIFA ARE MORE POWERFUL I PRESUME BUT THEY ARE IN EFFECT ONLY A BIGGER MORE GLORIFIED EFA. THEY DID SORT THE ITALIAN LEAGUE OVER THE FINANCIAL MALPRACTICE THERE.PERHAPS THEY SHOULD SORT OUT THE ENGLISH LEAGUES .IF THE THREE FROM POMPEY ARE CONVICTED THEN IT COULD BE SYMPTOMATIC OF ALL LEAGUE OWNERS  IN WHICH CASE  FIFA OR EVEN THE LAW SHOULD INTERVENE AND CHANGE THINGS BY TIGHTENING THE FIT AND PROPER RULES OF EVERY CLUB IN ALL THE LEAGUES .....GOOD ARTICLE CHRIS

Pirate wrote re: It's the Premier League, stupid
on Mon, Jan 18 2010 12:41 PM

Superb article. I've long said the protest are wasted when aimed at the owners. The PL are the ones culpable for the domestic game in Engalnd as a whole and unfortunately Pompey are bearing the brunt.

I don't like Platini, but I'm beginning to hope he manages to get a system across the board in all leagues that brings the game back to the people a la the Bundesliga and removes the huge debts involved in football these days.

Iain McInnes wrote re: It's the Premier League, stupid
on Mon, Jan 18 2010 1:14 PM

CHOCKY

Not so, driving up player prices wasn't what got Pompey into the Premier League, we had some very good players that had cost us little or no transfer fees, albeit salaries might have been tasty (ie) Paul Merson, Arjen De Zeeuwe and Todorov. What we did was go into the market and throw money at it aka Chelsea, Man U and the like.

Nothing wrong with that on the back of a plan that has (a) a new stadium (b) accompanying marketing income (c) long term investment strategy (d) professional and experienced management. After 50 years of support I bought into that plan....why not?

What we didn't know was the stadium plan was flawed at best and pie in the sky at worst and the corresponding marketing income impaled on the back of it. That there never appeared to be a medium let alone a long term investment strategy and quite frankly the management team, especially our 'heroic' Chief Executive was being led by commissions rather than commitment!

The FA Cup was the most enjoyable of false dawns admittedly but certainly not the cause of the mess we're in today.

We're all entitled particularly in football to buy into a dream and it needn't always turn into a nightmare!

Who knows what the plot is now but how the combined talents of the most contrived middle east consortium can sort this lot out is beyond me but let's hope they're following a bright star in the sky.

pebbles wrote re: It's the Premier League, stupid
on Mon, Jan 18 2010 2:50 PM

nice article chris..insightful and thought provoking. learnt more reading this than i have watching any of the almost daily gloom reports on the news. hope your club doesnt lose its fingernails clinging over that abyss.

c h r i s wrote re: It's the Premier League, stupid
on Mon, Jan 18 2010 4:11 PM

>> Who knows what the plot is now but how the combined talents of the most contrived middle east consortium can sort this lot out is beyond me but let's hope they're following a bright star in the sky.

Cool

c h r i s wrote re: It's the Premier League, stupid
on Mon, Jan 18 2010 4:14 PM

Cheers Pebbles... it we don't lose our nails clinging on, you can be sure a few will be lost biting them...

pompeylee wrote re: It's the Premier League, stupid
on Mon, Jan 18 2010 6:57 PM

Chris, Referance you're last point about biting/losing nails that explains why all those nail shop's in town alway's seem busy.

MarkFromOz wrote re: It's the Premier League, stupid
on Tue, Jan 19 2010 7:51 AM

I have a plan to save us all Chris!

Perhaps it was said in jest at the time, but one of your previous articles was spot on.  

Instead of PROTESTING, we should be marching to A.C. Milan and becoming their feeder club :)

If we can just remind them of that one special night, I'm sure they'd bail us out - with their talented developing players receiving an apprenticeship in the so called "best league in the world".

Worldwide exposure for us (think of the income), a steady stream of talent, players joining Pompey in the hope of attracting interest from 'above', and no more hoping for a sugar daddy to come in and throw money around.

What is there to lose? :)

c h r i s wrote re: It's the Premier League, stupid
on Tue, Jan 19 2010 7:55 AM

Great idea Mark -I shall suggest it to the powers that (might) be...

Lee, was that you buying pink 'varnish?

French Pete wrote re: It's the Premier League, stupid
on Wed, Jan 20 2010 12:23 PM

This article was mentioned on the News and rightly so. Really good and great to see that somebody in the town can write lucidly and emotively about our great team.

PUPPUP

Add a Comment

(required)
(optional)
(required)  
Remember Me?
© Copyright Sports Prototypes - 2008, 2009, 2010
Powered by Community Server (Non-Commercial Edition), by Telligent Systems